I totally agree with you Josnuggles. I don't know why they just didn't make the changes under the bonnet and leave the front alone. I have experienced each type of Windows since Windows 3 on floppy disks lol. They got really close with Vista Ultimate 64 bit. They tweaked Vista up and it became Windows 7 and I believe that they reached the peak with it. Not everyone wants the type of desktop versions like in Windows 8 + whatever and Windows 10. It seems to me that they are looking at the younger age group with regards to the fancy desktop. If it ain't broke don't fix it I say.Why did windows 7 have to be changed in the first place? Everything since has been awful - windows 8/8.1 and 10 are all horrible. We are forced to have app's on our pc on windows 10 that we can't uninstall. WE SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO CHOOSE WHAT WE WANT ON OUR EXPENSIVE COMPUTERS. Also I have a thick black line down the centre of my desktop display. Changing the wallpaper doesn't work and it doesn't appear on my external monitor. I will certainly not be upgrading any more of my computers to this pile of rubbish they call an improvement!!!!!
just a note, after that last update (yesterday) I don't see that narrator popup now, I did a hot re start, and a cold re boot and I didn't see it. so I hope it stays gone and that's one more "fix" down. we'll see............
I had a problem getting both narrator and magnifier to stop running automatically on every boot. It was a simple fix but very aggravating to discover.
What ended up working for me was to get to "Ease of Access" from settings. Once there I made sure that the narrator button was turned to the on position (also this is the same process for magnifier). You will more then likely have to turn the narrator position switch from on, back to off, then switch it back to on again. This will force the other options located under the narrator on/off selection, to become visible again.
For some unknown reason, once you have booted with the narrator running on startup, these options disappear. After turning narrator on, off and back on again, you will see directly under the narrator on/off selector, another selection that was not available or even visible, until you turned narrator on, off and then back on again.
The selection you are looking for is now available. It is labeled "Start Narrator Automatically", switch that selection from on, back to off. After that, It really doesn't matter if you turn the narrator off or not. The next time you reboot, narrator (also magnifier if you changed that too) will not automatically turn on and run on every boot.
Obviously there is a simple error in Windows 10. Once you automatically boot with narrator or magnifier running, you will not see the option of "Start Narrator Automatically" in the ease of access options. It does not become visible again, until you turn the narrator (or magnifier) selection from on, to off and then back to on again.
If you try what you said, I'm sure it won't work. That is not what I'm saying to do.
Let me try to say it a little bit better. Go to your Ease of Access page from settings. In the narrator section, just turn on then off then back on, the narrator. Do not reboot at all while doing this. Keep turning narrator on then off until you see the selection below it become visible again.
The selection below turning the narrator on and off, will read "Start Narrator Automatically". It will become active again after you toggle the narrator switch on and off and back to on again. This selection "Start Narrator Automatically" is what you need to change to stop narrator from running on startup. It needs to be changed to the "off" position.
This selection "Start Narrator Automatically" totally controls if narrator runs on startup or not. Turning the narrator itself either to on or off, has nothing to do with narrator running on startup. Putting the narrator toggle in either position, will not stop narrator from running on startup.
If you can not see the selection under the narrator on/off toggle control that is listed as "Start Narrator Automatically" with a toggle switch that allows you to have control of that option to either on or off. Then you need to toggle the on/off switch turning the narrator from on to off, until you see that option become available again.
After you can see the "Start Narrator Automatically" selection become active again, you will then understand that you have the ability to control narrator to either run or not run, on startup.
It really is an easy fix. I'm just not smart enough to be able to explain it.
Can you see in your screen shot that your "Start Narrator automatically" control field is all light gray and you have no control to turn it back to the "on" position. This is going to be hard to explain, but it isn't really off. It's still on. This is a very minor flaw in Windows 10. One that is so small, it will probably be a long time before they correct it.
Can you also see that under the Narrator toggle that it's a very bright blue toggle switch and that you actually do have control of switching it either way. That is because it is working correctly. Your "Start Narrator automatically" switch shows you that it is off but it isn't. Also you have no control to turn it back on. That is because it is not working as it should. It is incorrect, in showing you it is off.
The "Start Narrator automatically" selection will change from it's light gray looking "false reading" that you see as off but it really isn't, into a very bright blue "live" toggle switch, showing up the same as your Narrator selection above, if you do this one thing.
Toggle your Narrator switch on and off as many times as it takes to get that "Start Narrator automatically" selection to turn into the same kind of bright blue selection you have for the Narrator.
This "Start Narrator automatically" switch is the only important toggle to control Narrator on startup. It must be a bright blue toggle that is controllable, to be working correctly. This light gray switch is not controllable and it is not giving you correct information.
Once your "Start Narrator automatically" selection becomes bright blue with a toggle switch that you actually have control of, it will give you two things. First it will show you that in fact it was not in the off position but actually will show itself in the on position. Second, you now have full real control of that switch and can really move it to the off position.
After you move the "Start Narrator automatically" back into the off position, you will notice that it is still a very bright blue toggle that you still have full control of. That is the way it should always look but there is a minor problem in Windows 10 that does two things.
It gives you a false reading showing you that it is off, when it really isn't. Second you actually have no real control of that very important option and it is not bight blue.
The only correction is to toggle the Narrator on/off switch several times back and forth from on to off if necessary. Continue to toggle on and off until the "Start Narrator automatically" toggle field becomes bright blue again, giving you full control. Only then can you really turn it to the off position.
I apologize for not being able to make it clearer. If you actually went through the process to correct this problem. You would understand the problem much better then I can explain it.
If you have the "Start Narrator automatically" showing a blue toggle and that switch to set to off, then reboot, it should solve your problem. All I can personally say, is that it worked for me. I have a hard time understanding why it does not work for you. I would think that all Windows 10 operating systems are the same but it looks like there is a difference, somehow. I guess it is above my pay-grade to be able to help you, sorry.
However I would have preferred to see a screen shot that showed me you had both sections turned to off, instead of on, which is what you are posting. That both sections were showing the toggle switch as blue, as yours does. Then hear that you rebooted with those two settings switched to off, but still had the same problem.
I can only assume from what you are saying, that you tried it that way also. If that is true, then you have other issues that I can not understand. Someone much smarter then me, would be needed to solve your individual issue.
I hope that you can solve it. Also that if you can solve it, that you post your solution to help others that have this problem. I agree with you that it is extremely disturbing. I was very happy to solve this problem with my Windows 10. So I thought I could help you as well.
Good luck. At least you solved your problem by using a different approach. Maybe for some people, that will be their only option as well. If so, you have helped them, more than I have you.
Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?
You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.